When I was younger, I was convinced that student loans are an anchor. I believed that the best course of action was to eliminate them as soon as humanly possible. Full stop – no further discussion needed. Paying off student loans ASAP was a sign of being a mature adult. One did not carry debt if one could pay it off early. Being debt-free was the Holy Grail!
Suffice it to say that my views on student loans have become more nuanced as I’ve aged.
Full disclosure. When I graduated from post-secondary, I had student loans of just under $15K. My salary was paid bi-weekly, so I made extra student loan payments from every paycheque. These were on top of my regular monthly payment. I was fortunate enough to receive bonuses at work, so my first two years’ worth of bonuses went towards my student loans. Within 2 years, those loans were gone!
For the most part, I still believe that student loans are an anchor for many folks. If you’ve got a $200, $400, $700 student loan payment every month, that’s a big chunk of money that isn’t being used to build a better future for yourself. It’s not going towards a down payment. The money isn’t being set aside for your “thirsty underwear” years. (Hat tip to Garth Turner at Greater Fool for that descriptive phrase!) Those funds aren’t seed money being deployed in your own business. Depending on your circumstances, it could take you a very long time to pay off your student loan debts. Time that can never be recovered.
Truth be told, I still encourage people to focus on paying off their student loans. After all, it’s good to have less debt. Do what you can to make extra payments. Set up a per diem and have that money sent to your student loans every week. Do it via automatic transfer. If it’s $1/day, then send make an extra payment of $7/week. If you can afford $5/day, then that’s an extra $35/week. And if you can swing $10/day, then you’re looking at extra payments of $70/week… which is a very sweet $3,650 per year. The higher your per diem, the faster the debt goes away. Make this extra weekly payment on top of your regular minimum monthly payment. If you’re fortunate enough to get a raise or income from a side hustle, then use some of that money to pay off your student loans even faster.
When my student loans were gone, I felt very proud of myself. A debt obligation had been lifted from my shoulders! I was one step closer towards being debt-free. Yay, me!
Nuance…
It’s been over 15 years since I paid off my student loans. And I’ve learned a lot about investing in the stock market. Had I paid the minimum monthly payments on my student loans and invested in equities… <sigh> … Well, I’d be the Retired Blue Lobster by now, and my student loans would also be completely paid off. All else being equal, my loans would have been paid off in 9 years and I would have an even larger investment portfolio. My money would have had an extra two years to grow and all those extra payments would’ve been invested for growth.
Make no mistake! I still believe that student loans are an anchor. Yet, I’ve also come to believe that investing the stock market for the long-term is slightly more important than paying off student loan debt ASAP. This is because the weight of that debt burden, i.e. anchor, is reduced in two ways. Firstly, the debt gets smaller each time you make your minimum monthly payment. Secondly, the debt becomes a smaller portion of your net worth as your investments grow over time. Eventually, the debt will be gone and you’ll have a nice cushion of cash in the form of your investments.
If you go hard on your student loans to the exclusion of investing, you’ll be debt-free sooner but there’s no cash-cushion at the end. If you’re fortunate enough, you’ll be able to immediately re-direct your former student loan payments to investing. It seems trite to say this but I will anyways. Focusing solely on paying down debt robs you of the time that your money could have been working hard for you in your investments.
Investing early is a key to building wealth.
I’m not talking about investing money in a single stock and hoping that you’ve managed to get in on the ground floor of the Next Big Thing. From my perspective, that path is simply gambling. If you want to gamble, save your money and go to Vegas – it’s a lot more fun to gamble in Vegas!
The kind of investing that I’m referring to involves holding a broad-based equity exchange-traded fund (ETF) over a very long period time. Regular, consistent contributions to this kind of product gives investors access to the entire stock market and removes the temptation to jump from one promising stock to another.
An ETF offers you the chance to invest in a lot of companies at once. While they’re hardly exciting, ETFs offer regular people the opportunity to invest in some of the biggest companies in the world. You don’t have to be a genius, nor do you have to be lucky. The Next Big Thing will eventually become part of the ETF’s holdings, so you’ll still wind up own a sliver of it. And you’ll have avoided the risk of investing all of your money in one single company.
You should definitely read The Simple Path to Wealth by J.L. Collins. He does an excellent job of explaining why and how this works. Rest assured that I am not being paid for mentioning this book.
Real estate is another way to make long-term investments for the future. To be explicitly clear, this is not my preferred method. I am not an expert in real estate investing. If this interests you, then check out Bigger Pockets. I follow this account on social media and I’ve learned a lot. Again, I’m not being paid for mentioning them.
Some people can’t do both.
Fair enough.
I appreciate that not everyone has this option of to investing while paying down debt. Maybe you don’t have the money to do both. Reality being what it is, money only stretches so far. Or maybe the thought of debt causes you psychological distress. If that’s the case, then pay off your student loans as fast as you can. They are an anchor on your wallet. They prevent you from investing in your future because they force you to pay for your past.
You’ll make the best choices that you can with the information and money that you have available.
However, there are those in my audience who have enough to pay off the minimum student loan bill while also investing. If you’re fortunate enough to be in these circumstances, then I strongly urge you to do both. It may take you years to pay off your student loans. That is time that you can never get back. It makes the most sense to be investing in the stock market or in real estate while also paying down your debts. Your investments should be growing while your debts are decreasing.
Student loans are an anchor. There’s no doubt about it. However, how your handle those student loans will drastically impact your wealth-building goals. I don’t have all the answers because everyone’s situation is different. I just want you to think long and hard about what will work best for you.
****************
Weekly Tip: If you must finance a car, follow the 20-4-10 rule. Always put down 20% of the car’s purchase price. Make sure the loan is for a maximum of 4 years. Do not let the car loan be more than 10% of your annual salary. When your loan is paid off, keep making the payment to your Next Vehicle Fund so that you can pay cash the next time around.