My Money Mistake – Investing vs. Paying Off a Mortgage

One of the eternal questions that’s raised in the personal finance world is whether one should be investing or paying of a mortgage. I made my choice 15 years ago. In hindsight, my choice could qualify as a mistake but, if so, it’s not the worst one I’ve ever made. As I’ve said before, personal finance is personal and it should be about what makes you the most comfortable when it comes to investing your hard-earned money.

I was raised to not carry debt. It’s a good lesson, and I can’t disagree with it too, too much. That said, there are nuances to debt that I did not learn nor understand until after I’d paid off my mortgage at age 34. I’m going to share my perspective of those nuances with you so that you have the information to make the best decision for your own life and goals.

Different Choices, Different Risks

Jordan and Leslie are both 30 years old when they finally buy their first house. They both have 25-year amortizations, and they both have an extra $1500 per month that can be used for investing or paying down the mortgage.

Jordan decides to pay off his home early. His extra $18,000 per year goes into making extra mortgage payments. He’s in line to pay off his home in 15 years when tragedy strikes. At year 14 of the amortization, Jordan loses his source of income and cannot make his mortgage payments. Within six months, he loses his house to the bank in foreclosure. After years of making mortgage payments, Jordan is left without a house and without an investment portfolio. He has to start over from scratch – find another job, build another down payment, start making mortgage payments all over again, figure out how he’s going to pay for his retirement.

Leslie makes a different choice because she knows that time lost can never be regained. Investments need to be made early so that they have the maximize time to grown. Leslie decides to pay minimum monthly requirement on her mortgage, which commits her to the full 25 year amortization. Leslie invests her extra $1500 per month by fully funding her TFSA and RRSP every single year. Once those two registered plans are maximized, she invests the remaining money in a non-registered investment plan through a brokerage. In short, Leslie chooses to invest $18,000 per year. As with Jordan, Leslie loses her employment income at year 14 of her mortgage.

Leslie’s not worried about losing her house. Why not? Her investments have grown quite nicely over 14 years. She has money in the bank. Her dividends and capital gains are enough to provide her with cash flow to pay the mortgage. They’re not yet enough to replace her entire former income, but they’re enough to keep her afloat until such time as she finds another job.

Even if Jordan and Leslie hadn’t lost their jobs, Leslie would still have been wealthier than Jordan at the 25-year mark. Why?

Leslie’s investments would have had 25 years to grow while Jordan would have only had 10 years of growth. Even if he starts investing his entire former mortgage payments the day after his mortgage is paid off, Jordan’s investments will not grow as large as Leslie’s. Her investments have had an extra 15 years to grow, assuming the same rate of return for both portfolios. Both Jordan and Leslie would have a paid-off homes at the 25 years mark, but Leslie would also have a much bigger cash cushion than Jordan.

Hindsight is 20/20.

Now, don’t get me wrong. The logic of this example was lost on me when I took out a mortgage on my home. As a matter of fact, I don’t even think I saw the options presented this way until after I’d paid off my home. If I’d seen it sooner, I would have atleast thought about it while paying off my biggest debt.

With the benefit of hindsight, I now realize that I should have followed Leslie’s lead. It’s been nearly 25 years since I took out my first mortgage. Had I kept that mortgage and invested my money instead, I’d be that much closer to financial independence. Instead, I chose to become debt-free in my early 30s and have been diligently investing in the stock market for the past 15+ years.

My parents taught me to stay out of debt, and I heeded their advice. Was I wrong to do so? Not really… Yet, if I had learned about more about investing and the compounding of time, I would have made a better-informed decision. I might have better appreciated what it meant to lose those early years of compound growth as I worked very hard to pay off my home in 5 years.

Since you’re best-placed to know your own life goals & dreams, you will make your own choice. Investing vs. paying off a mortgage is a major financial decision. The consequences of the choice won’t be known until long after you make it.

My hope is that you make an informed decision. While you can’t know the future, you can influence it by making wise choices and planning accordingly.

There’s nothing wrong with changing course, if necessary.

If you’re currently making extra payments but you’re doubting that choice, then know this. It is perfectly okay to change your mind. When you know better, you do better. Maybe you stop the extra payments for a few months while you stuff your RRSP and your TFSA. Perhaps you decide to alternate – one month the extra money goes to your mortgage and the next month it goes to your investments. You have to do what makes you most comfortable. And if you decide to keep paying off your mortgage, then do so with the full knowledge of what that might mean for your future.

We no longer live in a world where the majority of people have pensions. For the majority, saving for retirement is up to each individual person. Lifetime employment with the same employer is no longer the standard. Committing to decades of mortgage payments without the security of gainful employment is risky. In Canada, houses are ridiculously expensive so mortgages are often several hundred thousand dollars. I understand why getting rid of such a large debt is a huge priority for people. At the same time, getting out of debt shouldn’t diminish the responsibility you have to funding the Care & Feeding of Senior You Account.

When I think about my own choice through the lens of maximizing my wealth, I feel that I made a mistake and that I should have kept my mortgage for as long as possible in order to invest. Yet when I consider the fact that employment is not guaranteed and funding retirement is on the shoulders of the employees, I think I was wise to eliminate my mortgage as fast as possible.

Will I have the absolute maximum amount for my retirement? No, but I’ll still have enough and that’s what matters most.