The question often arises about whether it’s better to invest your money or to pay down debt.
My position is that you should do both. The reality is that the younger you are, the more time your money has to compound if invested. From the tiniest acorn did the mighty oak grow, and all that. So if you’re younger, you have time on your side. More time means a longer investment horizon, which means larger returns by the time you retire.
On the other hand, debt inhibits the growth of your net worth. The longer it takes you to pay off your debt, the more interest you pay to your creditors. This is not an ideal situation. Instead of paying interest to your creditors, you should be earning a return on your investment. However, you can’t earn any returns if you don’t have the money to invest.
So here’s my proposal – invest while you pay off debt. Why can’t you do both? If the interest rates on your debt are lower than what you can achieve over the long term in the stock market, then pay the minimum on your debts in order to maximize your investment returns.
Mortgages
At the time of this post, 5-year mortgages in Canada can be had for 2.5% and lower. These are lifetime lows, which will likely be around for the next 2 or 3 years. If you’re in a position to lock in one of these ridiculously low rates, then you should seriously consider doing so.
If you have a mortgage and you’re paying the bank 2.5%, then I don’t want you to make extra payments on the mortgage. I want you to invest in the stock market for the long term. Over the long term, the stock market has returned an average of 7% to investors. I want you to learn about investing in index funds. Then I want you to pick one and to start automatically investing your money.
When mortgage rates are at historical lows like they are at the time of this post, there’s no sense in repaying your mortgage faster. So long as you can earn the long-term average stock market return, you’ll be earning 3 times the amount you’re paying on your mortgage. It would be stupid not to do so while you can.
Vehicle Loans
The same rule applies if you have a car loan at a reasonable interest rate. My definition of reasonable is that it is less than 6%. If you’re paying a higher rate, then you can split your investment money in half. One half will still be automatically invested. The other half will be sent to your vehicle loan so that it is paid off faster. When the vehicle loan is gone, then you can put the money back towards your investment. You’re also free to use your regular car loan payment for investing or for something else.
Let’s say you have a monthly car loan of $750 and you’ve got a 60-month loan at 6% (or higher). And you also have $500 per month that you’re investing for long-term growth. Divide the $500 in half, so that you’re now paying $1000/month on the car payment and directing $250/month into your investments. When the loan is paid off, you can go back to investing $500/month. You’ll also have $750 in your budget that no longer has to be sent to someone else. You can keep the $750 in your own pocket.
Oh, and the next time you want to buy a car? Save up for it first! If you can find the way to pay a loan of $750, then you’re just as capable of squirrelling $750 away every month until you can pay for your next vehicle with cold, hard cash.
Student Loans
By now, you should be picking up what I’m laying down.
In the interest of transparency, I will tell you that I graduated with $15,000 of student loans. I made it my mission to repay those loans within 2 years of graduating. With the benefit of hindsight, I have to say that my net worth would be higher today if I’d invested my money in the stock market and stuck to the 9-year loan repayment plan that I’d been on. My shaky memory suggests that my monthly payment had been something like $150. If I’d known then what I know now, I would not have made double and triple monthly payments to pay that loan off so damn fast.
Today, people are graduating with six-figure debts. And the word on the street is that they are not all finding high-paying employment with their very expensive educations.
I still maintain that if you’re in your 20s and 30s with a large student loan, it makes sense to pay the minimum on those loans and invest in the stock market. When you’re in your 20s and 30s, you still have 3-4 decades for the money to compound if you’re not planning on early retirement. Your income will go up as you expand your skillset, refine your expertise, and gain useful experience. Use 25% of your increased income to bump up your student loan repayment. Take another 30% to inflate your lifestyle just a little bit! Make sure the remaining 45% of your increase is invested.
The analysis has to be a lot more nuanced if you’re still paying off a six-figure debt in your 40s and 50s. The question of whether to invest your money or pay down debt isn’t as crystal clear. What I do know for sure is that it’s almost always a bad idea to retire with debt.
If you have student loans in your 40s and 50s, then you need to divide your investment amount between your portfolio and your student loans. Pay those loans off before you retire! Once they’re gone, go back to ploughing as much money into your investment portfolio as you possibly can. Your investment window is going to be smaller due to age. However, that doesn’t lessen the onus you have to yourself to fund your retirement.
Without a solid investment portfolio whose returns outpace inflation, a person on a fixed income is going to have to pay for everything with dollars that are always losing value. Believe me when I say that you don’t want to be paying off debt in retirement.
I’m telling you right now that you need to have a portfolio that can support you when you no longer have employment income. As I’ve said before, pensions are disappearing. It’s on you to set aside enough money for your golden years. Unless you remain healthy, getting older is going to suck enough on its own. You need not make things worse for yourself by being old and burdened by student loans debt.
The Exception!
If you’re carrying credit card debt, forget about investing until that debt has been eradicated. Credit cards carry double-digit interest rates. The chances of your investments giving you a return higher than the interest charged on credit cards are exceedingly slim.
Focus on getting out of credit card debt, then you can start investing your money. Here are the steps to getting out of credit card debt.
- Stop using your credit cards to buy things.
- Make extra payments to your credit cards until each card is paid off.
- As each card is paid off, do not use it again.
- When all cards are paid, take your former credit card payments and invest them for the long term in an equity-oriented index fund.
- Do not use your credit card without first saving up the cash in your bank account to pay for the eventual monthly bill.
**********
Weekly Tip: One thing to keep in mind that your portfolio doesn’t stop working just because you do. When you stop working, you won’t simply cash in your portfolio. Rather, you’ll structure your portfolio so that it’s continuously invested in manner that creates a cash flow for you until the day you die. This means that equities will continue to be a steadfast workhouse, ensuring that your portfolio lasts as long as you do.
