Tag: early retirement

My Criticisms of the Baby Steps

Based on my understanding of them, the Baby Steps have two main problems. One, the Baby Steps encourage people to work longer than they might otherwise wish. Two, people will pay higher than necessary management expense ratios (MERs).

One of the more controversial figures in the personal finance section of the Internet is Dave Ramsey. Among other things, he is famous for encouraging people to follow his Baby Steps.

When I was first starting down my own money journey, I happily devoured The Total Money Makeover. Even today, I still think that the Baby Steps are a great path for newbies who are looking for a way to get out of debt and to start building wealth. When I had student loans and car debt, I followed the Baby Steps and paid those off. Once debt-free, it was very nice to have some breathing room in my budget.

However, when I got to the step about investing 15%, I had to pause a little bit.

Criticism #1 – Working Longer than Necessary

My first concern with the Baby Steps is that they implicitly encourage people to spend 85% of their income once all non-mortgage debt has been repaid.

Allow me to exceptionally clear. THERE IS NOTHING WRONG WITH SAVING 15% OF YOUR INCOME! When there is a choice between saving nothing and saving something, always choose to save something. Then invest that money for long-term growth and go about the business of living.

However, I was fortunate enough to have learned about early retirement. I wanted to retire as soon as possible. Investing the recommended amount of 15% of my paycheque wasn’t going to do it for me. In short, investing only 15% of my income while spending the rest wouldn’t allow me to fulfill my goal of early retirement. I was not interested in working 30+ years if there was a viable option for me to still have a financially solid retirement while working for less than 3 decades!

As a result of my independent self-study, I had learned from other sources that a higher savings-and-investing rate meant a quicker path to financial independence. I’m certain that the Baby Steps will help most people get to a comfortable retirement at a traditional retirement age. And if the Baby Steps help someone to start their 15% investment plan in their 20s, I’m sure that they’ll have millions of dollars after 30+ years of work.

My life’s dreams didn’t involve working for 30+ years. My career has a lot of perks, but jumping out of bed each morning in gleeful anticipation of another day at the office is not one of them.

Fortunately for me, I had the ability to save more than 15% of my income once all my non-mortgage debt was eliminated. At this point, I seriously deviated from Dave Ramsey’s plan. Firstly, I paid off my mortgage in my mid-thirties. Then I took my former bi-weekly mortgage payment and started investing it. To be clear, that former mortgage payment was more than 15% of my take-home pay. I first maxed out my RRSP, then I maxed out my TFSA contribution room. Once that was done, I started contributing to my non-registered investment accounts. Over the years, I’ve benefitted from raises. Generally speaking, two-thirds of each raise went to my investments and the remaining third went to improving my present-day life by spending on those little luxuries that make me happy.

I am not encouraging anyone to deviate from the Baby Steps if they want to work for as long as possible. There are people in this world who love their jobs! Saving and investing only 15% of income works beautifully for these people. They get to spend their money today, while enjoying their jobs, and will still retire at traditional retirement age with a nice, fat cash cushion. If this is you, then I congratulate you on having found a way to make money doing something you love.

It just seems to me that the Baby Steps should say “invest 15% or more of your household income in retirement.” Adding those two little words would plant the seed that retirement can come sooner if you so wish. I’ve met more than a few people who’ve expressed the desire to quit working, but cannot yet do so because they need the paycheque. For these folks, saving the recommended 15% doesn’t get them closer to their goal of retiring sooner rather than later.

Criticism #2 – Paying Higher-than-Necessary MERs

My second issue with the Baby Steps is related to Dave Ramsey’s love of mutual funds. I’ve listened to him on YouTube where he consistently exhorts his listeners to invest in mutual funds.

In the interests of transparency, I admit that there was a time when I invested in mutual funds. I was younger and less knowledgeable about the costs of equity products. It’s been years since I divested myself of those products and moved into exchange traded funds with VanguardCanada and iShares. There was one main reason that I exited from mutual funds and went into exchange traded funds.

Mutual funds are consistently more expensive than exchange traded funds and index funds. This is because mutual funds charge higher MERs than their ETF/index fund equivalent. Think of the MER as the cost of the product. The returns on my mutual funds were not twice as good as the returns on my ETFs, even though the MER might be twice as high (or many multiples higher!) on a mutual fund than on an ETF. If the mutual funds’ performance had justified the higher price, then I would have continued paying a higher price. When I realized I could get the same performance for a lower price, I hastily moved out of mutual funds and put my money to work in ETFs. I’ve never regretted my choice.

So when I listen to Dave Ramsey talk about how wonderful mutual funds are, I have to ask myself why wouldn’t he tell his listeners to invest in equivalent yet cheaper ETFs? The same performance for a lower price seems to be a good thing for the people following his advice.

I have never heard a persuasive explanation for why people should pay higher MERs when an equivalent and cheaper product readily available.

Take a look at this MER calculator. It demonstrates that higher MERs result in smaller portfolios over any given period of time, all else being equal. The longer you’re investing your money, the bigger the MER-bite. Whenever possible, invest in an ETF or an index fund instead of a mutual fund. You should not be paying an MER higher than 0.3%.

So that’s it in a nutshell. Though they are a great starting point, I hope that I have articulated my two biggest problems with the Baby Steps. I sincerely hope that this blog post has given you more information about how to influence how much longer you’ll have to work. The secret is to invest more today so you don’t have to work as long tomorrow. Whenever you do invest, pick exchange traded funds instead of mutual funds to keep costs down and to maximize the amount of money working on your behalf. Lower MERs ensure that a higher percentage of every invested dollar works for you as you pursue your investment goals.

At the end of the day, the choice of how much and where to invest is yours. If you want to work for as long possible, while paying more in investment costs, then follow Dave Ramsey’s plan to the letter. If you’d like to have the option of attaining financial independence as soon as you can,then invest more than 15% of your next income and choose ETFs over mutual funds.

Mistakes with Money

Not a single one among us is born knowing how to use money perfectly. Our skill with money comes from making mistakes and learning from them.

For my part, I’ve made several notable mistakes with money over the years. I’ve written before about how I failed to take action with my investment plan for 5 full years. That one still hurts when I think about it. It took me 5 years before I finally rectified that situation by committing a good chunk of my paycheque towards my automatic savings plan. Now, I benefit from using dollar cost averaging to invest my money on a regular basis.

I hate to admit it but choosing to invest in dividend products instead of equity products is one of my biggest money mistakes! Had I started investing in equity ETFs instead of dividend ETFs way back when, then I’d be in a position to retire today…even with the recent volatility in the stock market.

Sadly, this money mistake cannot be un-done. I have been investing in a dividend portfolio since 2011, instead of a broad-based equity exchange-traded fund. The financial media has spent the last 3 months talking non-stop about the pandemic’s effect on the stock market, and how it has brought the 10-year bull run to an end. It’s true – the market took a deep fall in March. However, it has bounced back. It’s still quite volatile, and – in my completely amateur opinion – the stock market will continue to be volatile for the next 2-3 years.

I’ve been forced to realize that one of my biggest mistakes with money was to delay investing in equity ETFs. I’ve only just started investing in equity investments in 2019! It’s true that I managed to catch almost the very tail-end of the bull market, but the smarter play would’ve been to start investing in equity ETFs back in 2011… ideally, back in 2006.

Water Under the Bridge

‘Tis true. I can no more turn back the hands of time than I can lick the spot between my own shoulder blades. We make our choices then we take our consequences.

I shouldn’t be too, too hard on myself. Nine years of consistent investing has yielded a nice little cash flow for me. While my monthly dividends are in the 4-figure range, they’re not quite enough for me to retire just yet. I equate my little army of money soldiers to income from a part-time job that I don’t have to actually perform. Truth be told, it’s nearly a perfect side hustle since it’s money I earn without the sweat off my brow. How cool is that?

So why am I divulging one of my biggest money mistakes to you?

Two reasons. First, people in the personal finance world don’t talk about their mistakes with money nearly enough. The only regular mention I see of this reality is on the ESI Money website, where the millionaires who are interviewed are asked about some of their errors with money. I think it’s important that people realize that everyone who is good with money has made their own mistakes with it. Like I said at the beginning, no one is born as an expert with money.

Secondly, I don’t think that there’s any reason for you to make this mistake yourself. You can just as easily learn from someone else’s mistakes as you can your own. The more information you have, the more likely you’ll be to make a decision that best fits your particular circumstances. I firmly believe that people make the best decisions they can with the information that they have at the time. When you know better, then you do better.

Hard-Won Truths

Money mistakes are unavoidable. Mine isn’t the worst one in the history of the world, and it certainly won’t derail my financial future. And, let’s be honest – I ought not complain too much. I earn a small boatload of dividends month in and month out. How bad of a decision could I have really made 9 years ago?

My investing journey isn’t over. And I’m sure that I will make different mistakes in the future, but I just don’t know what they are yet. I still have choices and options for my money. I can choose to continue building up my army of money soldiers. The other option is to start investing in equity ETFs and take part in the stock market’s recovery. I’m quite confident that the stock market will continue to trend higher. It’s recovered before, and it will recover again. A third option is to simply coast on what I’ve already invested a la Military Dollar, so that I can spend today’s money on today’s things – home renovations, landscaping, a new vehicle, spa treatments, whatever…

I want you to accept that mistakes with money are an inevitable part of investing. That’s why it’s so very vital that you continually learn about it throughout your life, and that you put what you learn into practice. Invest as much as you can as early as you can. Invest for the long-term. Keep your mitts off your investments by simultaneously building an emergency fund for those emergencies that will crop up in life. Live below your means and stay out of debt. Save, invest, learn, repeat – this is a recipe that works.

By following these foundational principles with your money, the impact of your money mistakes will be minimal rather than nuclear.

**************

Weekly Tip: Set timelines for your goal so you know which ones are short-term, which ones are medium-term, and which ones are long-term. Generally, short-term goals are the one to be accomplished within the next 12 months. Things like vacations and concerts would fall into this category. Medium term goals are one that take between 1 and 5 years to accomplish. Think new vehicle and down payments on a home or a business. Long-term goals are those that will take longer than 5 years. Common examples are retirement and paying off a mortgage. Once you have a timeline, then you’ll be in a better position to prioritize where your money goes and to segregate your money so that each goal is funded.