Future You - Millionaire on the Prairie

Your Tax Free Savings Account is for Investing!!!

Hear me now! Your TFSA should be for investing. Don’t use it as a savings account for your emergency fund or as a sinking fun for stuff.

In 2024, the contribution room for the TFSA will go up to $7,000. Please don’t tell me that you can’t afford to save $7,000. What can you afford to save? Whatever that amount is, that’s the amount I want you to contribute. Then I want you to squeeze your budget a wee bit more and add in a little extra. The more that’s invested, the happier you’ll be.

Let’s say you can afford to save $1,000 per year. That’s a little less than $20 per week. If you invest that $1,000 each year in your saving account, you might earn 3% each year on your money. After 30 years, you’ll have saved $30,000. At a return of 3% per year, this nifty little Future Value calculator says that you’ll have $49,002.68 in the bank. In other words, you’ll have gained $19,002.68 over 3 decades. This is a bad return on investment.

You could do way better.

If you invest that same $1,000 each year into the stock market and earn an average return of 8% over that time frame, you’ll have $122,345.87. Over the same 30 years, you’ll gain $92,2345.87 – more than 3 times what you invested.

Do you see why you should use your TFSA to hold the investments that are going to give you a bigger return over a long period of time? You’ll have way more money in your kitty at the end of your working life and that money will not be taxed once you start withdrawing it to fund your retirement.

Play around with the values in the calculator. If you can squirrel away $2000 every year – or $40/wk – so much the better. Don’t worry that you can only invest smaller amounts right now. Over time, you’ll be able to invest more. Also, your investments will be generating dividends and capital gains. Re-invest those and think of them as contributions to your future. Compounding is slow at first but it starts to get very sexy and very interesting once a few years have passed.

Do not take money out of your TFSA unless it is the direst of emergencies. You should have a separate emergency fund. Keep that money in the bank. You’re not trying to invest your emergency fund. It has to be there when you need it so accept the 3% return that your bank is offering you. The money that’s in your TFSA should be invested in a broadly-diversified, equity-based exchange traded fund. Or you can invest in a broadly-diversified, equity based index fund. These types of ETFs and index funds invest your money in the stock market.

Notice how I said that your investments in the stock market will likely earn an average of 8% over a 3-decade time span? It’s an average because the stock market is volatile. Some years, the stock market will be down but other years it will be up. However, over 3 decades, the stock market will definitely be higher than it is today.

So invest in the stock market and leave it alone. Set up an automatic transfer so that you’re investing from every paycheque. Once you’ve done that, you go about your merry way and let time in the market work its magic on your money.

F.I.R.E. – A Refreshing New Perspective

For those who don’t know, F.I.R.E. is the acronym for Financial Independence, Retire Early. It’s a financial point of view that has gained traction in the past 10-15 years. People live significantly below their means in order to grow their money as fast as possible until they no longer need to work. Once they hit that point, they are considered financially independent. If they wish, they can choose to retire early at that point. There are a multitude of websites and blogs devoted to the F.I.R.E. way of life. I will admit that my personal finance coming-of-age was heavily influenced by the initial hardcore tenets of FIRE.

For a long time, I easily adopted the face-punching viewpoint of Pete who runs Mr. Money Mustache even though I was not going to give up some of things that he clearly eschewed. For a little while, I was also enamored with the draconian thriftiness espoused by Jacob’s on his website, Early Retirement Extreme, even though I would never choose to live that way. I was constantly searching for stories of people who lived well-below their means because I wanted to see how far I was willing to go to have money for my investments. When I found a poster on YouTube who only ate once a day in order to save money for investing, I realized that I had limits. Starving when you don’t have enough money is one thing. Purposely starving yourself in order to invest money is offensive to me. I decided to stop seeking the extremes.

Lately, a refreshingly new perspective has emerged. In my view, it is healthier and more welcoming than what I learned. The concept is an homage to living your best life while investing your money. Your money should be used to make your life as good as possible. This doesn’t mean going into debt. It doesn’t mean working forever. It does mean being laser-focused on that which is most important to you. Debts eventually get paid. Salaries increase, one way or another. Consistent contributions to investments will churn out capital gains and dividends. At some point, the gap between the cost of your monthly necessities and the cash flow coming to you will widen to an appreciable amount. This is called your disposable income. The new perspective is about figuring out how to spend that disposable income in a way to brings the most joy and happiness into your life.

I find the new perspective more persuasive than I would have even 5 years ago. One of my biggest challenges is finding balance between living today to the fullest while saving and investing just enough for tomorrow. Two authors come to mind. They’ve articulated ideas about living each day to the fullest, without ignoring the onus to take care of Future You. Specifically, I’m thinking about Ramit Sethi of I Will Teach You To Be Rich and his exhortation to live your rich life now. The other author is Bill Perkins, who has encapsulated the essence of the new perspective in his book book, Die With Zero.

What I like most about the new perspective is that it offers a sense of balance. It gives people permission to enjoy the present, and to enjoy spending a little bit of money today. The new perspective recognizes that time is fungible – once gone, it can never be reclaimed. Accordingly, everyone should figure out what is most important to them and spend their money accordingly in order to maximize the utility of their money while securing their financial future.

Ramit Sethi encourages people to pursue their rich life today. As I understand his message, he doesn’t want you to wait 10-15-20 years to start living well. He wants you to determine what you want and to figure out if you can incorporate it into your life today. Mr. Sethi advises people to ruthlessly cut out the stuff that doesn’t matter so that they can focus their money on the things that do.

I love this idea! For my part, cable TV is unimportant. I cut it out of my life 8 years ago, and I don’t really miss it too much. I can’t host Grey Cup or Super Bowl parties, but that’s the extent of the drawbacks to not have cable in my home. What I do love is traveling to new countries. Before the pandemic, I was able to fund 3 trips to Europe in the space of 4 years. For me, that was a huge accomplishment. My rich life definitely includes travel!

In Die With Zero, the author’s position is that dying with too much money means that you have deprived yourself of experiences that could have enriched your life. This book really challenged my views about spending, saving, and investing my money. Truth be told, my mind was blown! First of all, how could a person die with too much money? Was that even a thing? I really had to slow down and contemplate what the author was saying.

Speaking only for myself, this book forced me to consider whether I was spending money in ways that made me happiest. I’ve been saving consistently since age 21. I’d finally visited a fee-only financial planner to get an objective opinion on whether I could hit my financial goals. (The answer was a resounding “Yes!”) By the time I read Die With Zero, I was comfortably past the Coast F.I.R.E. point in my money journey. I was ready to contemplate the idea that I might not have been using my money in the best way possible. After reading this book, dying with un-spent millions no longer seemed like the wisest choice.

It’s truly not my intention to be the richest person in the graveyard. There are experiences that I’d like to have which will require me to open my wallet. Though I’m not entirely convinced that I should die just as my net worth hits $5.47, I appreciate the ridiculousness of dying with millions of dollars to my name. That money will only benefit my heirs. The opportunity for me to benefit from the money dies the moment that I do. While I intend to leave something to my heirs, I want to help and not hinder. There is an intrinsic value in attaining your own personal goals. I won’t deprive them of the chance to experience the pride of accomplishment.

Right now, I’m still searching for the sweet spot. In my humble opinion, the new perspective is going to gain traction. There are those who hate their jobs and want to leave as soon as humanly possible. To those unfortunate masses, I encourage you to change jobs or find a new career. Life is too short to be miserable at work. If changing jobs isn’t an option, then know that I completely understand why you’re willing to sacrifice time today and gamble that you’ll have the time tomorrow to enjoy your money when you eventually do quit.

There will always be hardcore adherents to the “sacrifice everything in the short-term to retire ASAP” view of F.I.R.E. However, that path to financial independence and early retirement is not palatable to everyone. As with most lessons to be learned in life, it is up to each of us to take what we need and to leave the rest. We alone are the ones who know best what we truly desire from our precious time here on Earth. We owe it to ourselves to learn new ideas, try them out, see if they work, keep them if they do, discard them if they don’t, and to do it all over again.

Banks are not evil – they’re simply a tool.

Truth be told, it took me a very long time to realize that banks are a tool that will help me achieve my personal finance goals. Every three months, the Big Banks release their earnings. More often than not, those earnings are in the billions, if not the hundreds of millions. And people start frothing with anger at the size of those quarterly earnings. Ink is spilled all over the Internet about how banks are evil and their earnings are obscene.

Two days later, the angry mob has moved on to some other topic upon which to unleash their rage. The banks go back to the business of earning more money so they can hit their next quarterly target.

And I wonder to myself if any one person in the mob realized that banks are a tool?

How banks make money

First off, I want to be very clear that I’m not an expert on the banking industry. I’m just an online citizen who has watched banks operate for the past 35+ years. I even used to work as a bank teller, which was an incredibly educational experience. However, being a bank teller and being a banking expert are two wildly different things.

I’ll share with you what I know.

Banks take money from depositors then lend it to borrowers to earn money. This is the heart of banking. Everything else is a detail.

Depositors have bank accounts and they expect to earn interest on their deposits. As we all know, most bank accounts pay less than 1% interest. Every so often, an online account has a higher rate but it’s usually not anything to get overly excited about.

Banks lend money to people at rates that are higher than what they pay to their depositors. See, from the bank’s perspective, the 1% interest rate is a liability because the bank owes money to someone. Money that’s lent out to borrowers is an asset because it’s going to earn money for the bank.

If the bank owes Depositor 1% per year on a $10,000 bank account, then the bank has a $100 liability since it has to find a way to pay $100 to Depositor in a year’s time. How does the bank do that?

Easy. The bank takes the Depositor’s money – $10,000 – and loans it to Borrower at a rate of 5%. Borrower has promised to repay the bank $500 in a year’s time, because 5% of $10,000 is $500. The Borrower’s $500 debt is the bank’s asset.

The bank collects $500 from Borrower, and pays $100 to Depositor. The bank keeps the $400 spread for itself. Now, I’m sure there are expenses that go along with running a bank, procuring loans, administration of bank accounts, and staffing costs. Whatever is left after paying those expenses is the bank’s profit.

Banks are good at making profits.

Understanding the spread between what is owed to depositors and what is earned from borrowers is what keeps banks profitable.

So how do you turn this to your advantage?

It’s very simple, Gentle Reader. Banks are a tool for you as soon as you buy your first bank share.

Remember how I said that bank earnings are reported quarterly? One of the best features of banks is that they pay dividends to their shareholders. The more bank shares you own, the more dividends you’ll receive.

I used to get irate over bank fees. How dare the bank charge me for using my money? The little vein in my temple would visibly throb if ever I saw so much as a $1 taken from my account to cover an ATM withdrawal, or for anything else.

Eventually, this financial annoyance was removed from my life through 2 actions that I took. First, I opened bank accounts with institutions that did not charge bank fees for daily banking. I was no longer paying bank fees every month. Secondly, I started earning money from everyone else who chose to continue paying bank fees. I bought shares in banks and cashed the dividend cheques every quarter.

I can confidently say that the idea of bank fees no longer enrages me. Even if I do mess up and bounce a cheque, I might have to pay the $35 NSF fee. However, I know that I’ll be getting my money back in a few weeks’ time via my next dividend payment. That fee is a nuisance, but hardly a reason for me to get upset.

Banks are necessary.

I firmly believe that everyone needs atleast two bank accounts – a chequing account and a savings account. The chequing account is for your day to day money. It’s for receiving your paycheque, buying your groceries, paying utilities bills, and the expenses of day-to-day life. Your savings account is for your emergency fund. It’s meant to be a liquid pool of funds that can cover 6-12 months of your monthly expenses. Some people argue that an emergency fund can be 3 months of expenses. I’m a big believer in the idea that more money is better when an emergency strikes so it can’t hurt to have more than the minimum.

Banks are not evil, in and of themselves. Used properly, they facilitate the transfer of money into your investment account. You know that I’m a huge fan of automatic transfers. I’m a proponent of paying yourself first. A portion of every paycheque should be sent to your investment account, so that it can start working to ensure the Future You has a financially comfortable lifestyle.

For my part, I have several bank accounts. And all of them are designated for a specific purpose. Some accounts hold money for my annual travel. (Even during the pandemic, I’ve socked away a few coins for the eventual day when I feel comfortable enough sharing a plane with others.) Other accounts hold money for my annual insurance premiums and property taxes. I have an account for little luxuries like my theatre subscription to Broadway Across Canada. There’s also an account for maintenance and repairs to my home.

Again, banks are a tool – they’re not evil. Learn to use them properly and you’ll find that they offer many great methods for handling your money. Better yet, become a shareholder and receive a slice of their profits every three months. I’ve no doubt you’ll enjoy the feeling of the banks paying you instead of the other way around!

Taking Care of Future You

Quick! Take a look at your current net worth. If you had known 10 years ago that it would be what it is today, would you have been angry if you had been forced to save more money???

The reason I ask is because I’m getting older. And the older I get, the more I notice things. One of the things I’m noticing is that my friends are getting older too. And they’re starting to make worrying noises about not having saved enough for retirement. These disquieting rumblings are leading me to wonder if perhaps people shouldn’t simply be forced to save for their retirement.

It’s Easy to Put Off Saving

Want to know why I’m such a huge fan of automating your savings?

It’s due to the fact that automation removes freedom of choice. I know myself. If I to deliberately choose to siphon money from my paycheque to my future, then I wouldn’t. I’d go through that money like a hot knife through butter! I’d be no further ahead financially but I’m sure I’d have more stuff – clothes, electronics, whatever…

I’ve curbed my ability to spend away my retirement savings by setting up automatic transfers. My paycheque comes in – the automatic transfers are triggered – I spend whatever’s left over.

Yet, I’m realizing that a lot of people don’t use automation to improve their financial futures. To be fair, I’m not talking about people who don’t have any fat to cut. Sadly, lots of people are living by the skin of their teeth and an automated savings plan won’t help those people.

I’m talking about the people who do have fat to cut. The ones who can cut back without eliminating all the little extra in life in order to fund their future financial goals. Many of them don’t do so… a situation that I find perplexing.

There’s Little to No Urgency

Perhaps the Ones-Who-Can simply don’t because retirement is so far away. It’s in the distant future, so why worry about it now when it won’t be here for a very, very, very long time?

Good question.

The answer is that tempus fungit, which is Latin for “time flies”. Yes, I’m old enough that I took a semester of Latin in high school. It still blows my mind that this year was my 30-year anniversary of graduating high school!

Your retirement will be here before you know it. Everyone gets the same 24 hours in a day. And they pass by at the same speed for all of us. No matter how busy you are, no matter how full your life is of other priorities, believes me when I say that you will get old…unless you die. Sorry to be so blunt, but it’s the truth. The only people who aren’t getting any older are the ones who have already passed.

Regardless of how far away it feels, your retirement is on the horizon. Saving up enough money to pay for it is a priority that you should focus on throughout your life.

Money From Others…

Yes, that’s right. It’s up to you to pay for your own retirement. Whether you’ll earn CPP, OAS or GIS (or Social Security and its equivalents), the amount of money you get from the government won’t be enough.

If you’ve been promised a pension, then all you have right now is a promise. The harsh reality is that pensions can fail. Think of a pension as a repository of deferred pay. Your employer pays you less today with the promise that they will pay you after you’ve retired. When a pension fails, it means that the employee who did the work doesn’t get paid as he or she was promised. It sucks and it’s unfair, and it causes a lot of havoc to pensioners who can’t turn back time and go back to work.

You should be saving your own money to supplement whatever you receive from the government and your pension. If the government and/or your pension still has money to pay you in your dotage, then that’s great. If not, then you’ll be very happy that you made the choice to tuck a little something away over the years. Err on the side of caution and start saving for your retirement.

It’s Vitally Important

There’s not much more to say at this point. You know how happy you are when you’re hungry and you eat something? That awful hungry feeling goes away and you can go on about your daily life.

You will continue to be hungry when you’re retired. You’ll still need shelter, a few clothes, access to transportation, some entertainment once in awhile. When you’re retired, I promise you that you will still yearn for your creature comforts – much in the way that you do today. In order to acquire them, your retirement funds will have to take the place of your paycheque.

Gathering sufficient retirement funds is an integral step in taking care of Future You. For the vast majority of us, it’s going to take a very long time. So unless you’re next to destitute, take immediate action. Set up a plan whereby you funnel some of today’s money towards tomorrow’s financial needs. I promise that you won’t regret doing so when the time comes to live off your retirement nest egg.

Yet…

I suspect you’ll read this, think it’s a good idea, and go on about your lives. There might be one or two of you who actually take my suggestion and plant their money tree. The rest of you… not so much.

All of us will need money until we draw our last breath. That’s the world we live in. And that’s why I’m starting to come around to the idea that people must be forced to save for their retirement. It cannot be optional. If it’s optional, then people will choose not to do it and that’s a bad choice. No one is telling you to give up all of the things that make you happy today in order to save for tomorrow. Instead, I’m encouraging you to cut back a little bit. This is so you’ll have the money you’ll need for Future You. Isn’t taking care of Future You worth a little bit of sacrifice today?

******************

Weekly Tip: Use your tax refund in a way that allows you to pay down some debt (30%), to invest in the future (50%), and to enjoy the present (20%). Life is about balance and enjoying the journey along the way.