Category: Wealth Creation

Commission Free Investing is Fantastic!

Allow me to be very transparent, right from the start. I’ve had a non-registered investment account with BMO Investorline for decades. They’ve recently introduced a list of exchange-traded funds that can be purchased for free. Let me tell you say it again. Commission-free investing is fantastic!

I suspect that this move to providing commission-free purchases is in response to newcomers such as Questrade and WealthSimple. I don’t have an account with Questrade or WealthSimple, but it’s my understanding that their platforms both allow investors to buy ETFs for free.

This is wonderful. Commissions on investments through brokerages can run from $4.95 to $9.95. If you don’t have to pay them, then you can invest your former commission fee. Remember! The sooner you invest your money, the sooner it can start compounding for you. One of your goals during your accumulation phase is to invest your money as soon as you can. Investing without commissions allows you to do that.

For my part, I buy units in my preferred ETFs every month. Luckily, my paycheque is bi-weekly. That means, money shows up in my account every 2 weeks. I siphon off a chunk for investing. Every other paycheque, or every 4 weeks, I take my investment-money and buy more units in my preferred ETF. At the same time, my ETFs pay me dividends every month. While all of my ETFs are on the dividend re-investment plan (DRIP), there’s usually a little bit of dividend money left over after I’ve received my new DRIP-units.

For example, my ETF might pay me $100 in dividends. If my ETF is trading at $15/unit, then I only receive 6 DRIP-units valued at $90 (=$15 x 6). That leave $10 in dividends sitting in my account. Four weeks later, the same thing happens. I receive another $100 in dividends and my ETF is still trading at $15/unit. Again, my DRIP feature kicks into action and buys me 6 more units, leaving another $10 worth of dividends in my account. (For the ease of calculation, assume that my ETF’s trading price stays the same. In real life, the price of my ETFs fluctuates from month to month.)

Wait a minute – hold the phone! Now, I have $20 in “leftover” dividends. Yet the cost of each unit is still only $15. Since there’s no commission to buy, I simply do a trade for 1 unit at $15. There’s still $5 leftover in my account, since $20-$15=$5, but who cares? I’ve done all that I can to get as much of my money working for me as soon as possible.

This is why commission-free investing is fantastic! More of my money can be invested sooner. The more units I have, the more dividends I earn the following month. This is self-reinforcing cycle that increases my passive cashflow, via DRIP-units and commission-free units. As I’ve said before, passive cashflow is awesome. You work once – you invest money earned from your blood, sweat and tears – that investment pays you dividends. So long as you don’t spend them, those dividends earn you more dividends as they compound over time. What’s not to love about this process? Now that you know about it, you can create the same system for yourself.

Earn it once, invest it until retirement. Dividend ETfs have been the bedrock of my investment portfolio for the past 10+ years. Happily, I can report that my dividends hit the 5-figure mark years ago. At this point, I expect that they will be a very nice supplement to my other retirement income when my employer and I part ways. Up until a few years ago, commission fees constrained how often I reinvested my “leftover” dividends. Today, those fees no longer a concern. Whenever I have enough money in my account to buy a unit in one of my ETFs, I’m investing it immediately. The sooner my money’s invested, the sooner it can start to compound and to increase my passive cashflow.

Ever since commission-free investing has been available, I have done my best to take advantage of it. You should take advantage of it too!

Pension or Not, Feather Your Own Nest!

It’s up to you to feather your own nest, regardless of whether you have a pension. The first step is to take responsibility for Future You by investing some of today’s money for tomorrow. It is both risky and foolish to rely on your employer for your retirement income needs. You shouldn’t assume that your employer’s contributions to your retirement plan are going to be sufficient when you can no longer work for a living.

Simply put, a pension is a promise from your employer that there will be money for Future You when you quit working for that employer. While you’re employed, your boss sets aside money for your retirement. That money goes into the pension. It is then distributed to the former employees each month.

Under a defined-benefit pension, the employer contributes money to the plan and promises to pay you a fixed monthly amount when you retire. This is your pension payment, and it is calculated by a formula. The payment is derived from your years of service and your salary. In other words, you can figure out how much you’ll receive in advance of retirement. The longer you work, the higher your salary, the bigger your pension will be. Your employer takes responsibility for ensuring that there will be enough money to pay you a pension until the day you die. Your benefit is defined.

The defined-contribution pension works differently. Your employer promises to contribute to your pension plan. There are no promises about how much you’ll receive when you retire. Under this plan, it is the employer’s monetary contribution that is defined. Your employer takes no responsibility for ensuring what your pension payment will be when you retire. Determining the size of your pension payment is a responsibility that lies on your shoulders. You’re the one who has to ensure that the money is properly invested for the long-term. Your choices will determine if your pension payment will be big enough to pay your bills once you’ve stopped working. Under this pension, two employees working the same length of time for the same salary can receive vastly different pension payments when they retire. The difference is attributable to how each employee chose to invest their pension contributions.

Hedge your bets when it comes to funding your retirement.

No matter what kind of pension you have, you need to feather your own nest. Why? Simple – a pension is a promise, not a guarantee. If your employer goes out of business, your pension will be impacted. It may take years for you to receive the pension payments that you were promised. Just talk to some former retirees from Nortel or Sears Canada. They all saw their pension payments cut when their employers went bankrupt. What would you do if 30% of your paycheque disappeared today? Now imagine losing 30% of your pension payment when you’re too old to return to the workforce. What options would you have for replacing that chunk of your promised pension?

Having your own investment portfolio is like having insurance for your pension. Investing for the long term increases your chances of being able to live off the income from your portfolio. If things go in your favour, dividends and capital gains might eventually exceed your annual pension income. Every dollar earned by your investments is one that can replace a dollar from your pension just in case the worst happens to your pension. Think about it. The Nortel and Sears Canada employees with personal investment portfolios weren’t as badly impacted when their pension payments were cut. The income from their investments was available to replace the money cut from their pension cheques. Had they planned on spending the cashflow from their investments? Maybe, maybe not. The reality is that having that investment cashflow dulled the impact of the reduced pension.

Do Better for Future You

I know how seductive the pension promise is. It would be lovely to cast aside all responsibility for Future You’s financial health, to let “someone else” worry about that. It’s the path of least resistance, but it might be disastrous. You wouldn’t even know how disastrous until it was too late. Imagine working for decades then realizing that you won’t have enough money. You’ll be out of time to earn more money. At 70 years old, do you really believe that you’ll eagerly anticipate working another 10, 15, 20 years just to make ends meet?

And I recognize how persuasive the AdMan is! In a world where you’re constantly exhorted to live your best life, it’s hard to save for a future that is decades away. After all, living your best life is generally code for open-your-wallet-and-give-me-your-money. The AdMan won’t be there to pay your bills in your dotage. Trust me on that!

Again, a pension is only a promise. This is why you have to feather your own nest! Err on the side of caution and invest some of your own money for Future You. No one is suggesting that you become a miser. I don’t want you to give up all the things that you love in order to save for tomorrow. I recognize that no one is promised tomorrow. However, I do want you to admit that there’s little to no harm in investing a portion of today’s money for tomorrow’s needs. Having a pension and cashflow from your personal investment portfolio would be the best of both worlds. Why deprive yourself of that?

Start Today

The reality is that you have to worry about Future You. Living below your means isn’t a punishment. It’s an admirable way of governing your financial life. Doing so will maximize your comfort when you no longer can, or want, to work. Money invested for the long-term will generate annual income for you, regardless of the pension plan you’re in.

Shave a little something off of each paycheque and invest it for tomorrow. I would advise saving 25% of your net income, but you know your finances better than I do. If you can only start with $10, then start with $10. Every penny counts, but you have to start somewhere. As your income grows, as your debts are eliminated, increase the amount that you’re investing. Once you’ve saved a portion of your paycheque for the Care and Feeding of Future You, then spend whatever’s left however you see fit.

Feather your own nest. The worst thing that can happen is that your pension shows up every month. In addition, your investment portfolio would be churning out dividend and capital gain payments every year. You’ll have two sources of income in retirement. How could Future You have any complaints about that?

The Basics Never Change

No matter how you slice it, the basics don’t really change. This blog is about money, so I’ll stick to the financial basics.

  1. Live below your means so you have some money to save and invest.
  2. Invest your money so that it grows over time.
  3. Go back to step one and repeat.

Everything else is about the details.

  • Where should the money be invested?
  • How low should the management expense ratio be?
  • Are mutual funds better than index funds?
  • Should one invest in index funds or exchange traded funds?
  • Is real estate better than the stock market for investment returns?

Start where you are, and go from there. One of the best tools I’ve found for managing my own money is a spreadsheet. Thanks to Numbers, I’ve been tracking my expenditures for the past few years. I could’ve used an app on my phone, but I prefer to personalize the spreadsheet to my own requirements. An app has a built-in structure that may not be suitable for me.

By tracking my expenses, I’ve been able to see where I splurge and where I don’t. The past two years haven’t produced as sharp a drop in expenses as one would have thought. I spent just as much in 2020 & 2021 as I did in 2019 & 2018. Yet, in the past two years, I haven’t been to a concert, a movie theatre, overseas, or inside of restaurants. I’ve been at home, partaking in Netflix, homemade food, and lots of computer games. Despite my at-home-hiding-from-coronavirus existence for the past two years, my annual expenditures have been the same or slightly more than they were in the Before Times.

I’m paying the same amount of money to purchase fewer things. That’s called inflation.

Despite the arrival of this particular money-eater, the basics haven’t changed. I still have to live below my means and invest for growth. My spending power will hold its ground against inflation so long as my returns are higher than the inflation rate.

You owe it to yourself to spend a little bit of the present thinking about the Care and Feeding of Future You Fund. It need not be a lot of time. After all, life is meant to be enjoyed and not wished away. The right amount of time is however long it takes you to set up an automatic transfer from your chequing account to your investment account. When you get paid, a chunk of money should automatically be sent to your investments. Then you forget about that money and go back to your daily life, doing what makes you happy.

Three weeks of 2022 are already in the past. Time flies so very fast! It’s important that you don’t let procrastination stop you from sticking to the basics. You need not know everything before you start. Instead, you start today and you learn as you go.

Get some books from the library. Do a Google search. Spend some time at YouTube University. Check out the education section of Investopedia. Maybe start following some personal finance bloggers. You don’t have to understand everything before you set up an automatic transfer. Have the money accumulating so it’s in place when you’re ready to make your first investment.

In the interest of transparency, I want to tell you a bit more of my story. I started with guaranteed investment certificates. I didn’t understand that GICs don’t beat inflation and that my money wasn’t growing the way I needed it to. At the time, I was concerned with safety. I didn’t want to lose my money. Perfectly understandable! You don’t want to lose your money either, right?

However, I borrowed books from the library and I learned about these things called mutual funds. They were offered by banks and they would give me better returns that GICs. So I switched my money to mutual funds. After a time, I learned about index funds and exchange-traded funds. They were better than mutual funds because they charged lower fees. Today, I’m still investing in ETFs while learning about crypto currency and NFTs. I’ve done some real estate investing but certainly not enough to consider myself an expert.

If anyone were to ask, I’d tell them that I have made many mistakes in my investments. I didn’t have all of the answers when I made my choices. I didn’t always understand the implications of my choices. If I could go back and make different decisions, then I most certainly would. That’s not possible so I continue to follow the first three rules articulated above. Save – invest – learn – repeat.

Wherever you are on your personal finance journey, you should be putting the basics to work for your money. You work hard for it. The least you can do is make sure that your money is working just as hard for you. There’s no time like the present. Take the first step today. Congratulate yourself. Then work on figuring out the next step. Take that step too. Before you know it, you’ll be saving and investing for Future You while still enjoying the gift that is today.

One Less Impediment!

For those about to invest, we salute you! There is now one less impediment between you and your financial goals.

Back in the dark ages, which is when I first started my investment portfolio, buying securities through a brokerage was expensive. For many years, I had automatic contributions withdrawn from my bank account by a private investment company. While I was busy learning about new products, individual investors were gaining the ability to access various products due to the rapid growth of technology. By the time I had learned about exchange traded funds and the importance of low management expense ratios, it was relatively cheap to do online transactions with my brokerage. It took some convincing but I finally moved my portfolio from the investment company to my brokerage. Regardless of who held my portfolio, I continued to dollar-cost average my way into the market each month.

Today, I’m happy to write that market competition has partnered with technology to make investing even easier for today’s investors.

As the number of financial services firms expands, the Big Banks are being forced to stay competitive with trading platforms that offer commission-free trades. This means that the banks’ brokerage arms allow customers to buy certain securities without paying a commission. In other words, it’s free to invest your money in more and more places!

This is is fantastic news. Why? It normally costs $9.95 to place a buy/sell order. For people who believe in dollar-cost averaging into the market, it costs roughly $10 each time a purchase is made. Long-time readers know that I divert a chunk of my paycheque to my investment portfolio every payday. Every 4 weeks, I buy more units in my chosen exchange-traded fund (VXC). I care not whether the market is up or whether it’s down. My plan is to buy and hold for the long-term. The execution of my investment plan is simply: buy more VXC units every 4 weeks and hold onto them.

So I was tickled pink when my brokerage*** announced that it would allow customers to purchase certain securities without paying a commission. My favourite dividend ETFs were both listed (XDV & VDY). Unfortunately, my happiness bubble was quickly pricked by reality. The fates have conspired to keep my equity ETF off the list of the commission-free securities!

This is great news!

Even though I’m still paying commissions, it’s fantastic that there are now so many commission-free options from which people can choose. The upshot is that there is one less impediment between people and their investment goals. Fees, MERs and commissions are all hurdles to clear on the journey to your investment goals.

Think about it. Any money that is not paying for commissions can be re-directed towards investing for your future. You and I both know that compound growth needs time to work. The sooner you start investing your dollars, the better.

Commission-free investing means that you can invest more frequently. Like I said, my dollar-cost averaging plan entails monthly purchases. I made 13 trades each year since I invest every 4 weeks. However, should there ever come a day that my ETF of choice makes it onto the commission-free list, I will be buying more units every two weeks.

Why increase the frequency of buying? Two simple reasons. It would be free to buy more frequently. Also, my money can’t grow unless it’s invested. I want to give compound growth as much time as possible to work its magic.

Do your due diligence.

My brokerage is with one of the Big Six banks. I’d be surprised if all of the big brokerages didn’t have their own list of securities that can be purchased commission-free. If you’re already investing, find out if you still need to pay commissions. And if your brokerage isn’t offering commission-free trades, ask yourself if its other benefits are worth paying commissions. If not, move your portfolio!

I spend a lot of time telling you to be cautious about the management expense ratios that you’re paying. (Again, any MER over 0.50% is way too high!) Commissions are another area where you should be paying close attention. Most big banks will charge you roughly $9.95 to make a trade through their online brokerage platform. It will cost even more if you make the trade over the phone with a human being, assuming that you can connect to real live person.

If you’ve already started to invest, then great – keep it up! Should your securities be on a commission-free list, even better. Now, you can bump up your contribution amount by whatever amount formerly went to paying commissions. Compound growth works faster if your money is invested now instead of later.

And if you’ve not yet begun investing for the Care and Feeding of Future You, what are you waiting for?

There is one less impediment to doing so. Start today!

*** Full disclosure – my investment accounts are with BMO Investorline. While I’d prefer to not pay a commission, I’m certainly not going to alter my investment plan due to this situation.

Buy and Hold Works!

As a non-expert financial person, my advice to nearly everyone is to adopt a buy and hold strategy because it works over the long-term.

When the pandemic was declared in March 2020, the stock market took a dive. And it wasn’t a sweet, gentle decrease either. It was a stomach-churning drop that saw me lose 1/3 of my portfolio’s value in the space of three weeks. At one point, I just stopped checking the value of my holdings. It was simply too painful!

Despite the drop and despite seeing years of growth wiped out in a matter of weeks, I continued to buy and hold. Every two weeks, a chuck of my paycheque went to my investment account. I stuck to my routine of buying units in my exchange-traded fund. In a world gone topsy-turvy due to a brand-new-to-humans virus, my investment schedule was the one constant that I could rely on.

Besides, I had learned my lesson from earlier market crashes. Back in 2011, the stock market crashed. I made a monumentally regrettable error when I stopped my contributions.

Wrong choices.

I was scared and naive, and I didn’t understand that the market crash was the very best time to be buying into the market. I wanted to wait for the market to recover a bit before adding new money to my portfolio. In reality, I should have been shovelling money into my investment account. Making hay while the sun rises and all that jazz.

Instead, I sat on cash in the bank for six months until I realized that I was being stupid. Who was I to know when the perfect time would be to re-start my contributions? I might be many things but a stock picking expert I was not!

So I picked a day and I just started investing again. And I haven’t stopped. As my income went up, I increased my bi-weekly contributions accordingly. A big chunk of each raise went to my investment account, while a little bit stayed in my pocket to increase my lifestyle. It’s the whole balancing act behind the principle of Save-Some-Spend-Some.

Instead of tying myself into knots trying to determine the very best time to invest my money, I simply invest my money every two weeks like clockwork.

COVID-19 didn’t matter

When the pandemic hit, and one third of my portfolio was obliterated in less than a month, I didn’t worry about my investment portfolio. I won’t say that I enjoyed seeing the daily decreases in my investment balances. What I will say is that I decided not to repeat the mistakes I made in 2011.

With age, comes wisdom… or so I’ve been told. In my case, there was truth to these words. Having missed an incredible investment opportunity 10 years prior, I vowed not to make the same mistake this time around. Even though the rollercoaster that is the stock market downward on one of its biggest descents, I continued to invest my money. I told myself that the losses would be short-lived and that my portfolio would recover.

My words proved prophetic. As anticipated, my portfolio has recovered quite nicely and I’m ahead of where I was just before COVID-19 became a permanent part of our world. I’m quite confident that the Care-And-Feeding-of-Blue-Lobster-Fund will be perfectly capable of replacing my income when the time comes that my employer and I part ways.

If nothing else, the pandemic has solidified my belief that buy and hold works. It’s a simple and straightforward strategy that works because you don’t have to tamper with it too much. The investor has two main hurdles. One, she has to open an account and start contributing. Two, she must continue to contribute while ignoring the talking heads, aka: financial experts who haven’t achieved notable wealth.

The investor doesn’t have to worry about timing the market. Buy and hold works because it puts the emphasis where it should be, on time in the market. It solves the problem of which stocks to buy. Purchasing units in a broad-based equity exchange traded fund means that the investor is buying into a diversified group of stocks. Stock picking is not involved. And that’s fantastic since analysis-paralysis is one of the biggest impediments to success in investing.

It makes sense, doesn’t it? If you happen to pick the wrong stock and lose money, then the odds are good that you won’t be overly eager to invest even more money into the stock market. You might even decide that you’ll never invest in the stock market again. To each their own… but that’s not a great response to having your butt kicked in the stock market.

My Next Steps…

The next move for me will be the same one I’ve been making for the past 10 years. When my paycheque hits my account, a big chunk of it will be automatically siphoned off and sent to my investment account. And on the appointed day, I will buy more units in my chosen investment vehicle. No muss, no fuss. There will be no worry about when to invest. And I won’t spend any of my precious, precious time on trying to find the next Tesla stock.

Instead, I will stick to what has worked in the past and what promises to work in the future. They say that there are no guarantees besides death and taxes. And they may very well be right. I’m going to propose that the buy and hold strategy ought to be viewed as guaranteed-adjacent.

Intergenerational Wealth – Start Them Young

Very recently, I learned that dear friends of mine had opened an investment account for their child who had recently turned 18 years old. My reaction was one of happiness because my friends are nurturing the seeds of intergenerational wealth for their family. The intent is to help the offspring build the habit of investing for the future, to have money in place for a down payment in 5-10 years, and to start retirement planning early. Helping their child today improves the odds that their grandchildren will also have a measure of wealth at some point.

Since the child is only 18 years old, a little will go a long way. As a matter of fact, steady contributions of as little as $50 per month can generate a big cash cushion 5 decades from now. Thats assuming the money is left to compound for the long-term goal of retirement. If the money is spent on a down payment, or other life expenses, then obviously the final amount will be smaller. The more withdrawals that are made, the smaller the final amount.

Earlier is better when it comes to investing.

I’ve never accepted the premise that it’s unwise to start saving small amounts in your teens & 20s. While those are supposed to be years of “carefree youth”, my view is that those years should not equate to carelessness with money. The two need not go hand-in-hand. Starting to invest early is rarely a bad idea.

To my way of thinking, the most important thing is to build the habit of saving and investing. I agree that $50 isn’t a life-changing amount of money. However, the contribution amount likely will not stay at $50 forever. At some point, the amount will increase to $75, then $100, then $200, and possibly more. Once it’s invested, the money will be working non-stop in order to maximize compound growth. How is that a bad thing?

Practicing good money habits is a key factor to succeeding with money as an adult. It’s never too early to build good habits in this area of your life.

It’s true that the 20s and 30s are expensive years for many people. Pursuing an education, buying vehicles, starting families, maybe even buying a home – these are all costly endeavours. I’m not here to argue otherwise. That said, the 20s and 30s are also the very best years for starting to invest. Most people have time on their side when they’re this young. Compound interest works best over longer periods of time.

Not the First Step

Allow me to be clear. My friends’ choice to set up their 18-year old with an investment account isn’t the first step in building intergenerational wealth for their family. I would say it’s the second-last step, or maybe the last step in their plan.

The first step was to set a good example of how to live below your means. My friends had certain priorities for their family and those got funded first. Debt did not become a permanent fixture in their lives. Every month, they paid the full balance on their credit card bills. They used the word “No” so that they could stick to their financial plan. Yet they still travelled as a family. My friends’ children all participated in extracurricular activities. The family built many great memories together and with friends, all while attaining their dreams and goals.

My friends’ next step was to start a registered education savings plan when their child was born. The RESP was fully funded every year. They knew that they only had 18 years before the money would be needed to pay for post secondary education costs. As soon as they could, they started saving for those expenses.

The third step was to pay off their mortgage when their child was in junior high. They did it by making extra lump sum payments where they could, maintaining a budget, and employing a little bit of delayed gratification. They worked hard to eliminate their four-figure monthly debt, aka: mortgage payment.

Between what’s in the RESP and their former mortgage payment, my friends’ child will not have to take on student loans to pursue post-secondary education.

Starting adulthood without student loans is a wonderful leg up on the journey to wealth. No student loans and a decent-sized investment account upon graduation from post-secondary education? Now, that’s an even better advantage! One could even call it a super-power… if one were so inclined.

If you’re lucky enough to be able to spare $50 or $100 per month before the major costs of young adulthood land on your shoulders, then take advantage! Start investing small amounts while you save for other goals. I’m not suggesting that you never have fun. Life is meant to be enjoyed at every stage, so enjoy it! However, I’m urging you to also realize that you also need to pay heed to Future You.

My friends’ offspring is being given a golden opportunity! How many of us wish we could’ve started investing sooner? Or had been encouraged to learn about personal finance in high school?

Even if your parents didn’t do this for you, find a way to do it for yourself.

Another Little Criticism

Learning about personal finance and investing has been a hobby of mine for the better part of 30 years… wow – that’s a long time! No wonder I make those odd noises when I get up from the couch…

Anyway, one of the first books that set me on my successful path was The Total Money Makeover by Dave Ramsey. I loved this book! I was in undergrad when I read it, and I promised myself that I would follow its tenets once I had graduated and was earning real money.

I’m not sad to say that this is one promise to myself that I’m glad I broke. See, while I still think that the debt snowball is a brilliant strategy for getting out of debt, I’m not so sure about the other steps.

In particular, I take strong issue with the step about only investing 15% of your income after you’ve gotten yourself out of debt.

What’s wrong with 15%?

On the fact of it, saving 15% is a great goal to strive for. My question for other personal financial afficianados is why stop at 15%? If you can comfortably save 20% or 30%, or even 50%, then why not do so?

See, somewhere along the line, I discovered FIRE. It’s an acronym for Financial Independence, Retire Early. Thanks to the vastness that is the Internet, I went deep down the rabbit hole of FIRE. I learned about people who saved 70% of what they earned, who’d lived on $7,000 for an entire year, who’d retired in their 30s! Eventually, I discovered Mr. Money Mustache – a fellow Canadian, whose face-punch imagery caught my attention from the word go.

The FIRE community is varied, like any other community. However, the one thing that they do seem to share is the belief that you need to save more than 15% to become financially independent anytime soon. There’s even this handy-dandy retirement calculator floating out in the world. (Plug in your own numbers – see if you like the answer!)

FIRE and Dave Ramsey seemed to have a lot in common. Both financial perspectives eschewed debt. They both emphasized having an emergency fund and saving for retirement. There are even many in the FIRE community who think Dave Ramsey is great, and happily pay homage to him.

Yet Dave Ramsey… is remarkably quiet on his thoughts about the FIRE movement.

Why is that?

Look. I can’t speak for Dave Ramsey or his organization. Maybe he’s a huge fan of FIRE, but it’s not part of his company’s mission statement. Or maybe he hasn’t heard of FIRE yet. There are a million reasons why he sticks to advising people to only save 15% of their after-tax income.

My theory is that FIRE is an anathema to employers, and Dave Ramsey is a businessperson who needs employees to work for him. As an employer, it makes no sense to encourage the pool of talent from which one draws to become financially independent. Employers have the advantage when employees are dependent on a paycheque. I think that this was most beautifully illustrated in the blog post of other fellow Canadians over at Millennial Revolution.

Allow me to be clear. I’m not for one minute suggesting that Dave Ramsey speaks for all employers. Of course, he doesn’t!

What I am saying is that it would not be in Dave’ Ramsey’s best interest as an employer to encourage the pool of potential employees to strive for financial independence. Think about it. Being FI gives jobs candidates more negotiating power since they don’t need the job to survive. The beauty of the FIRE philosophy is that it gives people choices, including the choice to work for personal satisfaction without consideration of the paycheque. After all, just because one is FI does not meant that one has to RE. If your job brings you joy and you’re also FI, then your are truly and wonderfully blessed. No need to retire early if you don’t want to.

Think about how terrifying that must be for an employer. If money is the primary tool to control the workforce, then what weapon is left when money is not effective? A financially independent pool of employees means the employers have to find another tactic to persuade people to work for them.

In my very humble opinion, 15% isn’t enough.

If you’ve paid off your debts and your budget has breathing room again, I don’t see why you should be implicitly encouraged to spend 85% of your money. Spending at that rate keeps you tethered to your paycheque longer than you may like.

Until recently, I didn’t really consider why Dave Ramsey doesn’t encourage people to pursue financial independence. Yes – some people won’t be able to save more than 15% of their income, even if they’re out of debt. I get that. If you don’t have it, then you can’t save it. However, those aren’t the only people who listen to him.

My question is more about why those who can save more are not being encouraged to do so.

Again, the only theory that makes sense to me is that he doesn’t want to use his platform to encourage financial independence. I find it odd. Firstly, I don’t believe that everyone who calls his show for help loves their job so much that they want to stay for as long as possible. Secondly, one of the very best things that money buys is freedom from doing what you don’t want to do. Thirdly, financial independence doesn’t mean that people become lazy and idle. Instead, it gives them the time to work on what truly makes them happy.

Currently, I believe the following. Pursuing FIRE status will always be an employee-driven social movement. Given its nature, it has to be. After all, as a group, employers cannot maintain their vice-like grasp on power where there is a financial balance in the employment relationship. When employees have the ability to walk away without negative financial consequences, employers run the real risk of losing employees’ labour. A vision remains a vision unless there are minds and bodies that can bring it to life.

The concept of financially independent employees is adverse to the employer’s interests. It’s hardly surprising that employers are not advocating that their employees put some of their focus on saving and investing.

Getting back to Dave Ramsey. His book was written long before the FIRE movement hit the mainstream. I do not believe that he suggested a 15% savings rate in an attempt to maintain the imbalance of power between employers and employees. That’s a pretty broad stroke, and it’s not one I’m intending to make.

What I am willing to say is that the practical effect of his advice to only save & invest 15% works to give employers the upper hand. I’ve had many good jobs in my lifetime, yet none of my employers has encouraged me to save and invest for my future. There’s never been any kind of nudge towards financial independence.

Think long and hard.

The sooner you invest your money, the sooner you can hit the target of being financially independent. There may come a day when you no longer love your job, for whatever reason. When that day comes, you’re going to need to have money in place to pay for those pesky expenses of living like food, shelter, clothing, etc…

I’m not telling you to not follow the Baby Steps. What I am telling you is to think about their practical effect on your personal finances. Take what works… leave the rest.

Are you doing what you want with your money?

Two thirds of 2021 are in the rearview mirror. You should probably spend a few minutes figuring out if you’re doing what you want with your money.

In other words, is your money moving you closer to or further from your life’s goals?

Maybe dealing with your money is just one-more-thing, and you’re dealing with enough. I get it, really! The pandemic is lasting way longer than we’d expected. The climate change consequences are no longer something to worry about later. The impacts are being seen and felt right now, every single day, all over the world. There’s a lot going on and it’s not all good, so that might make it harder to focus on mastering money.

Be that as it may, there have always been lots of significant events going on in the world. Gues what? There always will be. However, while we’re striving to make the world a better place, you still need to put your money to work. The state of the world doesn’t absolve you of the responsibility you have to Future You.

There is a straight-forward way for amateur investors such as ourselves to invest. It’s our best bet to improve the odds that we’ll be able to live comfortably when we’re no longer sending our bodies and minds to work every day.

Allow me to share my secret with you, again. Put your money on auto-pilot! You’ve got enough to worry about and investing money for your future need not be on that list. Set it up once then let the magic of computers do the rest.

  1. Set up an automatic transfer of a set amount of money from your chequing account to your emergency fund.
  2. Set up a second automatic transfer to your investment account. This can also be your retirement account.
  3. Buy units in equity-based exchange traded funds or index funds with management expense ratios below 0.25%.
  4. Don’t withdraw money from your investment account.
  5. Save. Invest. Learn. Repeat.
  6. Live on whatever’s leftover after these transfers have gone through.

Doing these few things will save your bacon when the time comes. You might feel that you want to spend all of your money right now. After all, tomorrow is promised to no one and you only live once, right? There’s a certain seductive allure to that perspective. Resist! You’re going to need money for all of the tomorrow’s headed your way. You might not know how many of them you’ll get, but the odds are very good that you’re going to need money for most of them.

The bottom line is that you should be doing what you want with your money. If you’re not, figure out why and do what needs to be done to change that situation.